Lunatic CHP cops go berzerk as female motorist successfully demands her rights under CA Vehicle code
By Martin Hill
LibertyFight.com
March 22, 2013


ABOUT THIS SITE MOST RECENT ARTICLESRADIO INTERVIEWSVIDEOS
ZIONISM FREEMASONRYFILMING COPSFIGHTING TRAFFIC TICKETS
9/11= Inside Job VACCINES= POISONRED-LIGHT CAMERASEUGENICS=MURDER
NEW SECTION: CATHOLICISM LibertyFight.com CLASSICSHISTORICAL QUOTESALL WARS ARE BANKERS WARS!


  • NEW: How I beat a Speeding Ticket in California Superior Court of Appeals (Without A Lawyer) Court documents included on page.
  • LibertyFight.com TRAFFIC TICKET ARCHIVES
  • Original 2008 article explaining the 'County Seat': Requesting the "COUNTY SEAT" -An easy way to beat a traffic ticket using a pre-emptive measure
  • Martin Hill of LibertyFight.com & Christie Czajkowski Discuss Fighting Traffic Tickets: - In this classic interview, which was conducted on July 1, 2009, Martin Hill of LibertyFight.com speaks with Christie Czajkowski of TruthBrigade radio discussing fighting traffic tickets, filming cops, beating red light camera tickets and the U.S. Police state.
    Update 3/27/13 3:17PM: Hello, and welcome to the California Highway Patrol. Thank you for visiting this article. I hope you like the publicity, because it's only just begun. To mitigate the liability of your degenerate officer's actions, your brass should re-train them properly. If they had trained their officers correctly in the first place, it would have save you a lot of grief, embarrasment and money. Too late. You have demonstrated a proven policy and practice of illegally denying people the County Seat and threatening to arrest motorists for demanding it. You had better respect the God-given civil rights of all people. Viva Cristo Rey!


    Two California Highway Patrol officers in Southern California have been caught on video trying their best to intimidate, threaten and coerce a woman to give up her rights while issuing her a traffic citation. While being issued the citation, the woman did not discuss the merits of the charge and never refused to sign the citation- she merely invoked, as is all motorist's right, what is very clearly outlined in the California Vehicle Code, Section 40502 (b).

    As CA law clearly states as outlined by the State legislature and on the Department of Motor Vehicle website,

    http://www.dmv.ca.gov/pubs/vctop/d17/vc40502.htm
    V C Section 40502 Place to Appear
    40502. The place specified in the notice to appear shall be any of the following:
    (b) Upon demand of the person arrested, before a judge or other magistrate having jurisdiction of the offense at the county seat of the county in which the offense is alleged to have been committed. This subdivision applies only if the person arrested resides, or the person's principal place of employment is located, closer to the county seat than to the magistrate nearest or most accessible to the place where the arrest is made.

    The point of contention between the woman and the officers was simply that she has a right to demand to appear at the County Seat, but the two traffic cops didn't agree. The primary officer, L. Harris (ID No. 14858), as well as his supervisor (pictured below) insisted that it was soley up to their discretion, which State Courts have clearly stated is not the case. They threatened to arrest the woman numerous times as well as screamed at her in rage and made her get out of her vehicle and sit on the cement. They also were not familiar with CVC 40502(b). In addition, the cops did not like being filmed. In a failed attempt to intimidate the videographer, Harris snarled "you can turn the camera off too", as well as instructing the driver to "tell your friend to get that camera out of my face," when the camera was actually nowhere near his face. He attempted this despite the fact that numerous Federal Courts and even the U.S. Supreme Court, in additon to the U.S. Department of Justice have clearly and repeatedly affirmed that filming police is an inherent right in America. Harris then told the passenger, who never said one word to him, to "stay out of this, it's none of your business" before slamming the vehicle door in anger. Within literally 40 seconds of the supervisor arriving on the scene, the unhinged boy-in-blue lost complete control and began screaming at the woman in a fury.

    The larger point of this video, regardless of where one lives or what their traffic laws are, is that if you know your rights and properly assert them with relentless determination, you can win. As the shortened-version video reveals, after detaining the driver for nearly 40 minutes while arguing, shouting at and threatening her, the two jackboot cops finally gave in and gave her the County Seat. That didn't have to be so difficult now, did it?


    As the excellent free website helpigotaticket.com explains,
    http://www.helpigotaticket.com/prevent/venue.html
    Change of Venue
    "In California if you live or work closer to the county seat than to the court which would normally have jurisdiction, you may demand a change of venue to the county seat per California Vehicle Code section 40502(b).
    "The ideal time to make the demand is before the officer writes the ticket, but you may legally make the demand any time before signing the ticket. (When an LA County deputy refused to give Geo. McCalip a change of venue, Geo. signed the ticket, "40502(b) Under Protest Geo. McCalip." This forced the judge in Compton to reassign the case to LA Metro (downtown LA), where the case was dismissed at arraignment).
    "The court has held that once you make the demand, if you meet the residency or employment qualification, the jurisdiction shifts to the court at the county seat ( Smith v. Glendale Municipal Court, 167 CalApp2d 534)."

    Case law precedent in California states even more strongly, in case there be any doubt, that officers have no discretion in the matter and that the motorist's demand for the County Seat is precisely that. It simply can't get any clearer than this, proving once again that the officers are not law enforcement agents, but rather revenue agents with disdain for the law and hatred for law-abiding people who dare to question their so-called "authority.":

    Smith v. Municipal Court, 167 Cal.App.2d 534 [Civ. No. 23349. Second Dist., Div. One. Feb. 3, 1959.] states, in part:

    "We are of the opinion that it was the intent of the Legislature to permit the person arrested upon a charge such as that involved here to designate the place at which he should [167 Cal.App.2d 538] appear and be tried. The section requires the officer to specify in the notice or citation the place at which the person shall appear and provides that this place shall be either before the nearest or most accessible magistrate within the county with reference to the place where the arrest is made or upon demand of the person arrested, before a magistrate in the county seat...

    "...Inasmuch as paragraph (c) (2) of the section provides for a demand on the part of the person arrested, we must assume that the Legislature intended the word "demand" to have its ordinary meaning and the import which that meaning gives to the statute.

    "...If he has a right to demand that as something due him, that right cannot be denied him at the discretion of the arresting officer.....

    "...for if the arresting officer may disregard the demand of the arrestee the right to make the demand becomes meaningless.

    "We hold therefore, that the arresting officer was upon the demand of petitioner required to specify the municipal court at the county seat as the place where petitioner should appear

    "...We find no merit in this [the prosecution's] contention, for to uphold it would permit the arresting officer to violate his duty to respect the demand of the person arrested as to the place of appearance and by his violation defeat the rights of the arrestee under the section. The arrested person, unless he resists arrest, has no means of asserting his rights under said section 739 except to do as petitioner [167 Cal.App.2d 541] did here, immediately demand that the hearing on the charge against him be transferred to the county seat in accordance with his demand to the arresting officer."
    [A more thorough summary excerpt of the ruling can be found at the bottom of this page.]


    Lunatic CHP cops go berzerk as female motorist successfully demands her rights


    * This article was featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , Economic Policy Journal, From the Trenches World Report , The Daily Paul (most popular of the day), Fourwinds10.net, and TheLibertyCaucus.com. The companion article and video Obnoxious CHP cop tries to make people stop filming him was Headlined on OpEdNews.com and made it to the most viewed list within moments. :-)]

    Martin Hill is a Catholic paleoconservative and civil rights advocate. His work has been featured in the Los Angeles Daily News, San Gabriel Valley Tribune, The Orange County Register, KNBC4 TV Los Angeles, The Press Enterprise, LewRockwell.com, WhatReallyHappened.com, Infowars.com, PrisonPlanet.com, Economic Policy Journal, FreedomsPhoenix, Haaretz, TMZ, Veterans Today, Jonathan Turley blog, The Dr. Katherine Albrecht Show, National Motorists Association, AmericanFreePress.net, RomanCatholicReport.com, WorldNetDaily, OverdriveOnline.com, Educate-Yourself.org, TexeMarrs.com, Dr. Kevin Barrett's Truth Jihad radio show, Strike-The-Root.com, Pasadena Weekly, ActivistPost.com, Los Angeles Catholic Lay Mission Newspaper, KFI AM 640, IamtheWitness.com, Redlands Daily Facts, BlackBoxVoting, The Michael Badnarik Show, The Wayne Madsen Report, Devvy.com, Rense.com, The Contra Costa Times, Pasadena Star News, Silicon Valley Mercury News, Long Beach Press Telegram, Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, L.A. Harbor Daily Breeze, CopBlock.org, DavidIcke.com, Whittier Daily News, KCLA FM Hollywood, The Fullerton Observer, Antiwar.com, From The Trenches World Report, and many others. Archives can be found at LibertyFight.com and DontWakeMeUp.Org.

    RECENT:

    Motorist puts police in their place at suspicionless internal checkpoint December 2, 2012 [Must see video- Featured on PrisonPlanet.com].

    Cop at Suspicionless Checkpoint Starts Barking Orders, But Then Flees from Camera [Featured on LewRockwell.com.]

    NOTE 7/28/13: Recently the front page of of my site has become too crowded, so I have created a LibertyFight.com Classics Page. I hope you enjoy perusing the site and reading over the body of work which I have compiled over the years. Thanks for visiting. :-)

    RECENT ARTICLES:

    To contact me or to receive the latest articles from LibertyFight.com join the mailing list by sending an e-mail request.

    When the U.S. government supplied ammo & military planes to kill thousands of Catholics September 18, 2013

    Ron Paul ignores pressure from Zionists, keeps scheduled speech to group at alleged 'Anti-Semitic Conference' September 4, 2013

    J.P. Morgan war propagandists plot to control the media: U.S. Congressional Record, 1917 August 30, 2013

    Rand Paul on Israeli groups: "I visit with them daily" August 13, 2013

    Outrage: Pervert TX Trooper who raped women on roadside re-hired by TX DPS, even though she has additional cases pending 8/11/13

    Not An Isolated Incident: Texas Troopers caught regularly conducting illegal searches, raping women 8/9/13

    200,000 RFID-chipped patrons enjoy slave-training at Zionist-run Lollapalooza in Chi-town
    Condom ads, police state tactics, illegal drug use, & religious desecration featured at smarmy pop-culture gathering

    Infowars compares baby-killers to "holocaust deniers"

    Coast to Coast "pulls it"- cancels scheduled conspiracy show after Dr. Kevin Barrett query August 2, 2013 [Featured on Veterans Today.]

    Why People don't file complaints against police civil rights violations July 28, 2013 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    LAPD tells residents: Ditch your guns, Get a dog & take a YMCA class instead July 22, 2013

    Obama White House: "The Second Amendment gives citizens the right to bear arms." July 22, 2013

    U.S. Government funding the very groups who are killing Christians July 14, 2013
    Top Catholic Patriarch on record saying that Western Nations "bear responsibility for what is happening in Syria"

    Neocon Glenn Beck calls for celebrating Ramadan by shooting all Guantanamo prisoners in the head July 12, 2013

    LibertyFight article launches viral worldwide coverage of DHS breaking driver's car window 7/12/13

    DHS at Internal Checkpoint breaks drivers' window, seizes all his stuff and doesn't charge him with anything 7/10/13

    In civil rights lawsuit, police admit "The passenger is under no obligation to comply with request" for ID

    Calif. govt. spied on cell phone users, recording age, gender, race, passengers, & more

    Disneyland "cops" writing citations to kids in subtle subservience conditioning program

    As Press Fades, L.A. Motorists Start Paying Red-light Camera Tickets Again (Even Though They Don't Have To.)

    This is what happens when a big rig driver falls asleep: Exclusive video and photos of wreckage - Massive July 4th Crash: Demolished Vehicles, Avocados Everywhere

    Martin Hill's DontWakeMeUp.org Featured in Major Trucking Magazine:
    The story about my lawsuit against the TX Troopers is currently featured on OverdriveOnline.
    Team driver to law enforcement: 'Don't wake me up' 6/21/13
    http://www.overdriveonline.com/team-driver-to-law-enforcement-dont-wake-me-up/

    U.S. Dept. of Justice admonishes Los Angeles Sheriff for numerous Constitutional Violations 7/2/13

    Fatigued Truckers Killing Troopers Everywhere as Insane Cops Continue to Revel In Waking Up Off-Duty Sleeping Drivers

    California Motorist beats 5th Seat-Belt Ticket Through the Mail With New Federal 'Rest Rules' Taking Effect July 1st, Feds questioned on why they already violate existing rules 6/18/13
    Letter to Feds on Driver Fatigue and following their own rules


    FLORIDA GOVT IN A FRENZY OVER BEING EXPOSED
    Florida state government agencies and law enforcement have been visiting my website every day for multiple hours since our expose on the Florida Highway patrol's illegal actions. They are also conducting internet searches to try and cover their @$$ legally.

    Florida Highway Patrol Spokesman claims right to violate 4th Amendment

    Psycho TX cop warns TV News of 'fatigued truckers' after defending cops who woke up sleeping trucker

    Watch these poor idiots turn in their guns for a few boxes of donuts. OutRAGEOUS!!

    Internal Documents in TX Trooper lawsuit: Cops admit "the passenger is under no obligation to comply with request" for ID

    Jews Suing Jimmy Carter over Palestine book represented by 'Dancing Israelis' Lawyer 5/29/13 [I was on Dr. Kevin Barrett's show May 29th discussing this article and related issues. The MP3 can be downloaded/heard here. 2nd hour.]

    Catastrophic Bridge Collapse reveals importance of sleep for Truckers as NTSB investigates sleep records

    Martin Hill & LibertyFight.com Featured in HAARETZ, Israel's oldest and most influencial newspaper

    CHP 'CHEATERS' Program Urges Californians to Snitch and Rat Out Their Neighbors

    9/11 Widow & lawyer sanctioned for motions which "reflect anti-Semitism in a raw and ugly form.": LibertyFight.com has obtained an exclusive copy of the court decision against 9/11 widow.

    Jane's Addiction/Lollapalooza frontman Perry Farrell confronted on Bin Laden, 9/11 by pro-Palestinian 9/11 truther: Grotesque mock baby-murder ritual plays out on stage while Zionist Farrell sings

    George Zimmerman lawyers will report "negative, hate or prejudice-based" web content to "proper authorities"

    Holocaust Revisionist David Cole resurfaces 15 years later as GOP Darling 'David Stein'

    Consumer Choice: A few Chewing Gums Without Aspartame Are Still Available


    U.S. Dept of Defense googling 'Bishop Richard Williamson Boston Bombings' 5/21/13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , SecretsOfTheFed.com , redicecreations.]

    AB 666, 'The Devil's Bill' Defeated in California [Featured on rattlereport.com , WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    9/11 Widow & lawyer sanctioned for motions which "reflect anti-Semitism in a raw and ugly form." 5/18/13
    LibertyFight.com has obtained an exclusive copy of the court decision against 9/11 widow. [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , IamTheWitness.com , RomanCatholicReport.com , Veterans Today , MarianiLawsuit , therebel.org , lunaticoutpost.com , dublinsmick's ,Stewwebb.com , Peoples Trust Toronto , grizzom blog.]

    15-year-old girl learns the truth about the holohoax, submits a report and gets an A May 17, 2013

    Highest Ranking Catholic Patriarch condemns lies and hypocrisy of the U.S. in Syria May 15, 2013

    City which warned "lock your doors and load your guns" to hold massive gun buyback program to disarm residents
    Protest 'Gun Buyback' Programs, slated across Southern California on June 1st

    Bishop Richard Williamson: "Boston Bombing Was Another False Flag, Only The People Waking Up Could Possibly Save America." May 14, 2013 [Featured on DavidIcke.com , truthjihad.com , factsnotfairies , Veterans Today , 2012indyinfo , Patriot Gun Shop , beforeitsnews.com , peoples trust toronto , WhatReallyHappened.com , The Aussie Digger , revolutionradio.org , TheInfoUnderground.com , z10.invisionfree.com , truth11.com.]

    As Press Fades, L.A. Motorists Start Paying Red-light Camera Tickets Again (Even Though They Don't Have To.) May 13, 2013

    'Advanced Close-Range Gunfighting' CEO responds to query on Gilkerson (AK47 wielding cop-shooter) May 10, 2010

    Man Who Open-Fired On Cops With AK-47 Had "Resistance To Tyranny" Book In Car 5/5/13
    Ron Paul, JPFO, "Tryanny Response Teams" lauded in book

    TX Senator on Gun-Toting Vet's Arrest: "Stories like these are why I filed SB897" 5/2/13 [Featured on WhayReallyHappened.com.]


    Bill protecting those who film police moves through TX Legislature 5/1/13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    Feds Re-Indict 65 year-old delusional man accused of plotting to kill abortion doctors [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , topix.com , infopig.com , bignewsnetwork.com , shovelcity blog , Progressive Democrats of America , OpEdNews.com , realclearliberty.com , scaruffi blog , marketfreedom.com. The FBI has also visited this article.]

    Corporate dinosaur media copying independent grassroots blogs verbatim 4/27/13
    CBS2 visits & copycats month old LibertyFight.com article on cell tower controversy [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    NY Police Commissioner Ray Kelly on Boston Bombings: "All Terrorism Is Theater" 4/27/13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , Conspiracy Theory Today , curezone.com , Salon Esoterica.]

    A visit to the Chris Dorner Big Bear Hideout: Retracing the final steps from burnt-out truck to mountain condo 4/25/13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    NOTE: Visit our new website DontWakeMeUp.Org - Trucker's Civil Rights for more information on the Federal Civil Rights Lawsuit filed against the Texas Troopers for illegally demanding ID. You can also join the mailing list for updates.

    DontWakeMeUp.Org Launched As Civil Rights Lawsuit Proceeds Against Texas Troopers
    Trooper facing civil suit denies threatening motorist with arrest, despite being recorded 4-16-13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    You may contact me here. To sign up for our mailing list send an e-mail request.

    Who says you can trust the government? NYPD lists police killed by 9/11 environmental toxins April 7, 2013 [Featured on RomanCatholicReport.com and WhatReallyHappened.com.]
    In the immediate aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, the U.S. government falsely assured police and rescue workers that the environment was completely safe.

    Stockton is bankrupt, but their police continue trying to stop people from filming in public April 2, 2013
    Cop Attempts to stop person from filming on public street [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , Red Pill News and Seznam novinek.]

    Oppressing the poor and defrauding a laborer of his just wages: "sins that cry out to Heaven for vengeance" April 1, 2013
    Also, Pope St. Leo I condemns "unrighteous and shameless avarice," and explains that "usury of money is the death of the soul." [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    Easter 1939: Father Charles E. Coughlin warns of the war propagandists, their system of financial control & their evil "blood business" [Featured on RomanCatholicReport.com , WhatReallyHappened.com , Republic Broadcasting Network, Fourwinds10.net , cottage-two , rustymetals.com , usapartisan, & scoop.it.]

    Man who hit cop in self-defense is acquitted, with help of friend's video footage March 28, 2013 [Featured on educate-yourself.org , WhatReallyHappened.com and strike-the-root.com.]

    Despite protests and risks, San Bernardino, CA Catholic Archdiocese plans cellphone tower at kids school for profit March 27, 2013

    CA introduces "AB 666", an evil scheme to fleece motorists and eviscerate their rights 3/25/13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , Rense.com, Economic Policy Journal , and RomanCatholicReport.com.]

    Obnoxious CHP cop tries to make people stop filming him 3/24/13

    Lunatic CHP cops go berzerk as female motorist successfully demands her rights under CA Vehicle code 3/22/13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com , Economic Policy Journal, From the Trenches World Report , The Daily Paul (most popular of the day), Fourwinds10.net, and TheLibertyCaucus.com.]

    Why I wasn't going to allow the squirly Walmart Guard to demand my receipt 3/20/13

    Remember the guy who called George H. W. Bush a murderous, Zionist, peice of $h!t at a Houston Pizza place in 2010? This story is about him and what he's been up to lately:
    Jane's Addiction/Lollapalooza frontman Perry Farrell confronted on Bin Laden, 9/11 by pro-Palestinian 9/11 truther March 18, 2013 [Featured on Veterans Today and Roman Catholic Report.]

    Ron Paul officially promotes his Israeli-smitten son Randy for President 2016 March 11, 2013

    NO, Obamacare does not include any provision for RFID microchipping March 3, 2013 [Featured on the Dr. Katherine Albrecht Show.]

    Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly blatantly lies about past NY gun confiscation on national radio January 20, 2013 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com and Republic Broadcasting Network.] [NYPD, The City of New York, The New York State Senate, and countless other spook/govt agencies have visited this article numerous times.]


    INFORMATION ON 'TEXAS-ISRAEL DAY':


    Internal Documents in TX Trooper lawsuit: Cops admit "the passenger is under no obligation to comply with request" for ID

    Catastrophic Bridge Collapse in Washington State reveals importance of sleep for Truckers as NTSB investigates the sleep records of driver
    This story illustrates the perfect reason why psycho pig cops must obey the law and not illegally disturb motorists.

    4/17/13: DontWakeMeUp.Org goes viral immediately after public launch: People from across the world along with Corporations, Universities, Law Firms, as well as State and Federal government agencies have visited DontWakeMeUp.Org since our release on Tuesday, April 16th. We will have an "our visitors" page outlining the government visitors soon.
    Cop at Suspicionless Checkpoint Starts Barking Orders, But Then Flees from Camera (4/17/13)
    Creepy DHS Supervisor tries to open vehicle door when motorist asks officer's name [Featured on LewRockwell.com , Economic Policy Journal , WhatReallyHappened, RomanCatholicReport.com , battlefourtimes, gunnyg , U.S. Constitutional Free Press , Flyover Press , Freedom Watch, Sodahead, and many others.]

    4/16/13: WOKEN UP AGAIN! The irony of, on the very day I launch my new website DontWakMeUp.Org, it happens. Again. Today. UNREAL. Watch how these lunatics change course the second they see the camera. Keep your cameras ready, folks! The article and video can be seen here.


    April 16, 2013: DontWakeMeUp.Org Launched As Civil Rights Lawsuit Proceeds Against Texas Troopers
    Trooper facing civil suit denies threatening motorist with arrest, despite being recorded
    [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com.]

    Motorist puts police in their place at suspicionless internal checkpoint December 2, 2012
    [Must see video- Featured on PrisonPlanet.com].

    How I Beat A Cell Phone Ticket In California

    Cell phone ban does not reduce accidents: California revenue scheme exposed as complete fraud



    Smith v. Municipal Court, 167 Cal.App.2d 534 [Civ. No. 23349. Second Dist., Div. One. Feb. 3, 1959.]

    "On June 23, 1957, petitioner was placed under arrest in the city of Glendale by a police officer of that city. At the time of the arrest the officer prepared a citation charging petitioner with the violation of section 476, subd. (c) 1 of the Vehicle Code for allegedly having made a right turn against a red light in violation of that section. Petitioner then demanded that the arresting officer specify in the citation as the place for him to appear the municipal court at the county seat, namely, Los Angeles. This the arresting officer refused to do and specified in the citation the respondent court as the place at which petitioner would, by signing the citation, promise to appear. Petitioner refused to sign this citation and was thereupon taken into custody by the arresting officer and removed to the Glendale police station where he was booked, fingerprinted, photographed and released on bail.

    "On June 24, 1957, petitioner appeared in the respondent court, objected to the jurisdiction of that court and demanded that the cause be transferred to the Municipal Court of Los Angeles Judicial District. His motion was denied and he was thereupon arraigned upon a criminal complaint...

    "...It is petitioner's contention that under section 739 of the Vehicle Code he had the right to select the court before which he would be obligated to appear and having made his demand that he be cited to appear at the county seat, the municipal court there was the proper court for the trial of the action and that the respondent court therefore acted in excess of its jurisdiction in proceeding to try him and abused its discretion in refusing to transfer the action to the municipal court at the county seat....

    "[1a] We are of the opinion that it was the intent of the Legislature to permit the person arrested upon a charge such as that involved here to designate the place at which he should [167 Cal.App.2d 538] appear and be tried. The section requires the officer to specify in the notice or citation the place at which the person shall appear and provides that this place shall be either before the nearest or most accessible magistrate within the county with reference to the place where the arrest is made or upon demand of the person arrested, before a magistrate in the county seat or a magistrate in the judicial district in which the offense was alleged to have been committed. It is respondent's contention that by the use of the word "either" in paragraph (c) of section 739 of the Vehicle Code the Legislature evidenced its intent to give the arresting officer the right to specify in the citation the place at which the arrestee should appear. We do not so read the statute. It is apparent that while the statute requires the officer to specify in the notice one or the other of the two places for the appearance of the arrestee, it does not leave to his discretion which of the two places shall be named. If no demand is made by the arrestee the officer must specify the place of appearance as before a magistrate within the county which has jurisdiction of the offense and who is nearest and most accessible with reference to the place where the arrest is made. But if a demand therefor is made by the arrestee the officer must specify as the place of appearance a municipal court within the judicial district at the county seat or at the demand of the arrestee, before a magistrate in the judicial district in which the offense is alleged to have been committed.

    "Inasmuch as paragraph (c) (2) of the section provides for a demand on the part of the person arrested, we must assume that the Legislature intended the word "demand" to have its ordinary meaning and the import which that meaning gives to the statute. "Demand" is defined as: "An asking with authority, claiming or challenging as due." The clear import of the statute is therefore to give the right to the arrested person to specify the place of his appearance and trial. If he has a right to demand that as something due him, that right cannot be denied him at the discretion of the arresting officer.

    "...for if the arresting officer may disregard the demand of the arrestee the right to make the demand becomes meaningless. Had the Legislature intended that the officer might at his discretion fix the place at which the arrestee should appear, it would have been a simple matter to eliminate paragraphs (1) and (2) of paragraph (c) and change paragraph (c)..."

    "...We hold therefore, that the arresting officer was upon the demand of petitioner required to specify the municipal court at the county seat as the place where petitioner should appear..."

    "...In arriving at this conclusion we have not overlooked the contention of the respondent that inasmuch as petitioner was taken into custody and did not sign a promise to appear that the provisions of section 739 cannot be applied. We find no merit in this contention, for to uphold it would permit the arresting officer to violate his duty to respect the demand of the person arrested as to the place of appearance and by his violation defeat the rights of the arrestee under the section. The arrested person, unless he resists arrest, has no means of asserting his rights under said section 739 except to do as petitioner [167 Cal.App.2d 541] did here, immediately demand that the hearing on the charge against him be transferred to the county seat in accordance with his demand to the arresting officer."

    web statistics