Jews Suing Jimmy Carter over Palestine book represented by 'Dancing Israelis' Lawyer
By Martin Hill
May 29, 2013


[Note: I appeared on Dr. Kevin Barrett's radio show on 5/29 to discuss this article and related issues. MP3 here (2nd hour).]

In February 2011, five Jewish individuals sued former president Jimmy Carter and his publisher Simon and Schuster for $5 million dollars in a class-action lawsuit over Carter's 2006 book "Palestine, Peace Not Apartheid." Three months later they withdrew the suit, but vowed to re-file it in state court. And it turns out that their Israeli lawyer took part in another infamous case which was also thrown out of court, the case of the Dancing Israelis!

The 2011 lawsuit against Carter alleged, in part, "As a former American president and as a self-proclaimed Middle Eastern affairs expert, and in some cases as a direct participant in the events at issue, the defendant Jimmy Carter knew that substancial and material portions of the Book were untrue, and has failed to advise the public, or other defendants of that fact," continuing "The book is filled with factual inaccuracies and falsehoods."

Alleging "Plaintiffs' injuries are the result of defendants' conduct," the suit claimed that the "Plaintiffs purchased and read the book, on the representation that it was a factual and accurate presentation of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In fact, however, numerous respresentations in the book, including, but not limited to the examples provided above, are false, inaccurate, misleading and deceptive and were written, marketed, and promoted intentionally, wantonly, and willfully with the intent to deceive, with a reckless disregard for the truth and to mislead the reader."

Legal Analyst Jonathan Turley, a law professor at George Washington University Law School, slammed the suit in 2011, called it a "bizarre," "disturbing and clearly frivolous lawsuit." Turley opined that the plaintiffs "should be held for Rule 11 sanctions in filing a vexatious and frivolous lawsuit," adding "The complaint is written like a press release without a thin pretense of legal claims. ... I fail to see the good-faith basis for this filing, which seems intended for public consumption. Federal courts are not forums to achieve cathartic satisfaction by venting views against an author.... this filing is neither creative nor excusable in my view. It simply takes objections previously heard in opinion articles and repeats them as legal claims..."

Turley explained "The first claim is breach of contract. The second claim is unjust enrichment. The third claim is negligent misrepresentation. The fourth claim is intentional misrepresentation. The fifth claim is the consumer protection act violations."

David Schoen, attorney for the plaintiffs, responded to Turley's criticism at the time in a rambling diatribe, which Turley had the courtesy to publish on his blog. Schoen practices in Montgomery, Alabama and states on his website that "David has a deep personal interest in and commitment to Israel and is constantly looking for ways to expand his professional involvement with Israel and Israel related issues."

Attorney Nitsana Darshan-Leitner, listed as 'Israeli co-counsel for Plaintiffs' on the Carter suit, insisted at the time of filing that "The lawsuit will expose all the falsehoods and misrepresentations in Carter's book and prove that his hatred of Israel has led him to commit this fraud on the public. He is entitled to his opinions but deceptions and lies have no place in works of history."

In May of 2011, however, only three months after the hysterical federal suit was filed, it was dropped.

Darshan-Leitner, the Israeli lawyer acting as co-counsel for Plaintiffs in the Carter suit, was coincidentally the lawyer who represented the infamous 'Dancing Israelis' who were arrested on 9/11/01. Darshan-Leitner, pictured here, is director of Shurat HaDin Israeli Law Center and according to her bio on the group's website, "has been leading the struggle to fight the Palestinian and Islamic terrorist organizations in the courtroom" since 1997. In 2004, Israelis Paul Kurzberg, Silvan Kurzberg, Israelis Yaron Shmuel, and Omer Gavriel Marmari filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against Attorney General John Ashcroft and wardens of the Federal Bureau of Prisons for their treatment in prison after their 9/11/01 arrests.The four were represented by New York attorney Robert Joseph Tolchin and Darshan-Leitner. They claimed that their detention was illegal and that their civil rights were violated, suffering racial slurs, physical violence, religious discrimination, rough interrogations, deprivation of sleep, and many other offenses. The lawsuit also stated "As Israelis and as Jews, plaintiffs themselves are sworn enemies of al-Qaida and Osama bin Laden."

According to press reports at the time the Dancing Israelis case was first filed in 2004, Nitsana Darshan-Leitner said: "The infamous arrest of these young Israelis on 9/11 has been used by anti-Semites worldwide as 'proof' of Israel's involvement in the World Trade Center attack. Our clients are seeking compensation for the harm they suffered in the MDC by prison officials. In addition, the law suit will serve as an important public forum to debunk the lie that Israel or the Mossad was behind the 9/11 terrorist attacks. It will show that there was no Jewish conspiracy as the Arab world continues to claim and put an end to this racist blood libel."

The Dancing Israelis lawsuit, however, was eventually dismissed because of the plaintiffs failure to serve the defendants properly as per the rules of the Federal Court; an absurd and completely avoidable reason. It's interesting that Nitsana Darshan-Leitner seems to have a pattern of issuing dramatic, self-righteous proclamations about vindicating the reputation of Israel, only to later slink off into the sunset unnoticed.

Simon & Schuster, who had called the suit against Carter a "chilling attack on free speech," announced in May 2011 that the "plaintiffs wisely withdrew their action. We hope that they will consider this the end of the matter." However, Plaintiff's attorney David Schoen said that the suit was dropped on a technicality and vowed to re-file it in New York State Court. That was two years ago. Nothing new about the case was reported until last month, when reported Jews Still Planning to Sue Jimmy Carter over Anti-Israel Book. (4/10/13).

It should be interesting to see what indignant proclamations Nitsana Darshan-Leitner makes to the media defending Israel, and then watch to see how the far-fetched lawsuit against Carter proceeds, if it does at all. Given the track record, I wouldn't bet on it.

RELATED: "Dancing Israelis" Arrested On 9/11 Later Sued The Govt, But Lost Their Case (11/6/12) [Featured on, and]

Martin Hill is a Catholic paleoconservative and civil rights advocate. He advocates limited Constitutional government, presumption of innocence, and individual liberty. His work has been featured in the Los Angeles Daily News, San Gabriel Valley Tribune,,,,, Economic Policy Journal, FreedomsPhoenix, Veterans Today,, The Wayne Madsen Report,,, The Dr. Katherine Albrecht Show, Jonathan Turley blog, National Motorists Association,, Republic Broadcasting Network, WorldNetDaily, Dr. Kevin Barret's Truth Jihad radio show, The Orange County Register, KNBC4 TV Los Angeles,,, Los Angeles Catholic Lay Mission Newspaper, KFI AM 640,,, The Press Enterprise, Redlands Daily Facts, BlackBoxVoting, The Contra Costa Times, Pasadena Star News, Silicon Valley Mercury News, Long Beach Press Telegram, Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, L.A. Harbor Daily Breeze, Whittier Daily News, and many others. Archives can be found at and DontWakeMeUp.Org.

RECENT ARTICLES: Response to HAARETZ & other media Regarding the Holocaust and Allegations of anti-Semitism

George Zimmerman lawyers will report "negative, hate or prejudice-based" web content to "proper authorities"

Holocaust Revisionist David Cole resurfaces 15 years later as GOP Darling 'David Stein'

Consumer Choice: A few Chewing Gums Without Aspartame Are Still Available

U.S. Dept of Defense googling 'Bishop Richard Williamson Boston Bombings' 5/21/13 [Featured on , , redicecreations.]

AB 666, 'The Devil's Bill' Defeated in California [Featured on ,]

9/11 Widow & lawyer sanctioned for motions which "reflect anti-Semitism in a raw and ugly form." 5/18/13 has obtained an exclusive copy of the court decision against 9/11 widow. [Featured on , , , Veterans Today , MarianiLawsuit , , , Republic Broadcasting , , , dublinsmick's , , Peoples Trust Toronto , grizzom blog.]

15-year-old girl learns the truth about the holohoax, submits a report and gets an A May 17, 2013

Highest Ranking Catholic Patriarch condemns lies and hypocrisy of the U.S. in Syria May 15, 2013

City which warned "lock your doors and load your guns" to hold massive gun buyback program to disarm residents
Protest 'Gun Buyback' Programs, slated across Southern California on June 1st

Bishop Richard Williamson: "Boston Bombing Was Another False Flag, Only The People Waking Up Could Possibly Save America." May 14, 2013 [Featured on , , factsnotfairies , Veterans Today , 2012indyinfo , Patriot Gun Shop , , peoples trust toronto , , The Aussie Digger , , , ,]

As Press Fades, L.A. Motorists Start Paying Red-light Camera Tickets Again (Even Though They Don't Have To.) May 13, 2013

'Advanced Close-Range Gunfighting' CEO responds to query on Gilkerson (AK47 wielding cop-shooter) May 10, 2010

Man Who Open-Fired On Cops With AK-47 Had "Resistance To Tyranny" Book In Car 5/5/13
Ron Paul, JPFO, "Tryanny Response Teams" lauded in book

TX Senator on Gun-Toting Vet's Arrest: "Stories like these are why I filed SB897" 5/2/13 [Featured on]

Bill protecting those who film police moves through TX Legislature 5/1/13 [Featured on]

Feds Re-Indict 65 year-old delusional man accused of plotting to kill abortion doctors [Featured on , , , , shovelcity blog , Progressive Democrats of America , , , scaruffi blog , The FBI has also visited this article.]

Corporate dinosaur media copying independent grassroots blogs verbatim 4/27/13
CBS2 visits & copycats month old article on cell tower controversy [Featured on]

NY Police Commissioner Ray Kelly on Boston Bombings: "All Terrorism Is Theater" 4/27/13 [Featured on , Conspiracy Theory Today , , Salon Esoterica.]

A visit to the Chris Dorner Big Bear Hideout: Retracing the final steps from burnt-out truck to mountain condo 4/25/13 [Featured on]

NOTE: Visit our new website DontWakeMeUp.Org - Trucker's Civil Rights for more information on the Federal Civil Rights Lawsuit filed against the Texas Troopers for illegally demanding ID. You can also join the mailing list for updates.

Cop at Suspicionless Checkpoint Starts Barking Orders, But Then Flees from Camera
Creepy DHS Supervisor tries to open vehicle door when motorist asks officer's name 4-17-13 [Featured on WhatReallyHappened, Economic Policy Journal, , , battlefourtimes, and many others.]

DontWakeMeUp.Org Launched As Civil Rights Lawsuit Proceeds Against Texas Troopers
Trooper facing civil suit denies threatening motorist with arrest, despite being recorded 4-16-13 [Featured on]

You may contact me here. To sign up for our mailing list send an e-mail request.

Motorist puts police in their place at suspicionless internal checkpoint December 2, 2012 [Must see video- Featured on].

Who says you can trust the government? NYPD lists police killed by 9/11 environmental toxins April 7, 2013 [Featured on and]
In the immediate aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, the U.S. government falsely assured police and rescue workers that the environment was completely safe.

Stockton is bankrupt, but their police continue trying to stop people from filming in public April 2, 2013
Cop Attempts to stop person from filming on public street [Featured on , Red Pill News and Seznam novinek.]

Oppressing the poor and defrauding a laborer of his just wages: "sins that cry out to Heaven for vengeance" April 1, 2013
Also, Pope St. Leo I condemns "unrighteous and shameless avarice," and explains that "usury of money is the death of the soul." [Featured on]

Easter 1939: Father Charles E. Coughlin warns of the war propagandists, their system of financial control & their evil "blood business" [Featured on , , Republic Broadcasting Network, , cottage-two , , usapartisan, &]

Man who hit cop in self-defense is acquitted, with help of friend's video footage March 28, 2013 [Featured on , and]

Despite protests and risks, San Bernardino, CA Catholic Archdiocese plans cellphone tower at kids school for profit March 27, 2013

CA introduces "AB 666", an evil scheme to fleece motorists and eviscerate their rights 3/25/13 [Featured on ,, Economic Policy Journal , and]

Obnoxious CHP cop tries to make people stop filming him 3/24/13

Lunatic CHP cops go berzerk as female motorist successfully demands her rights under CA Vehicle code 3/22/13 [Featured on , Economic Policy Journal, From the Trenches World Report , The Daily Paul (most popular of the day),, and]

Why I wasn't going to allow the squirly Walmart Guard to demand my receipt 3/20/13

Remember the guy who called George H. W. Bush a murderous, Zionist, peice of $h!t at a Houston Pizza place in 2010? This story is about him and what he's been up to lately:
Jane's Addiction/Lollapalooza frontman Perry Farrell confronted on Bin Laden, 9/11 by pro-Palestinian 9/11 truther March 18, 2013 [Featured on Veterans Today and Roman Catholic Report.]

Ron Paul officially promotes his Israeli-smitten son Randy for President 2016 March 11, 2013

NO, Obamacare does not include any provision for RFID microchipping March 3, 2013 [Featured on the Dr. Katherine Albrecht Show.]

Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly blatantly lies about past NY gun confiscation on national radio January 20, 2013 [Featured on and Republic Broadcasting Network.] [NYPD, The City of New York, The New York State Senate, and countless other spook/govt agencies have visited this article numerous times.]