Police Internal Affairs Investigators Confirm that Filming Cops in Public is 100% Legal
SEE ALSO: LibertyFight Filming Cops Archive


This all started one sunny day in July 2008. I was pulling into a store parking lot and suddenly saw a shaved-headed cop violently push down a little teenaged kid. Shocked to witness such a thing, I got out my digital camera and started filming. A plain-clothed detective then saw me and unsuccessfully attempted to interfere with my right to film. I filed a complaint against him and a police internal affairs investigation was instigated. Since the police asked to speak with me and were filming the interview, I brought my own camera along and filmed it too.

Since few people are inclined to watch a 50 minute interview, I have broken down the specific segments in which the two internal affairs police investigators repeatedly affirm that filming police in public is everyone's right. The following are transcript excerpts and video from that West Covina, California interview. The text of the complaint along with photos and video of the original parking lot incident can be found here. The entire 50-minute internal affairs interview can be seen here.
For clarity and identification purposes of the investigators, "Cop 1" is the white cop and "Cop 2" is the black cop.

Police Internal Affairs Interview Part 2 / 5

At minutes 0-2:

Cop 2: "Whether they're a reporter or not has no bearing, we WELCOME (filming)..."

Cop 1: "If you have the right to be there legally, you have the right to photograph or film whatever you can see."

Starting around At minute 6, I ask if it is the policy to allow people to film police detaining/questioning suspects in public.
Cop 2 explains: "we really don't operate in the dark. If you want to film it, and you're legally there and you're not gonna be in harms way, we dont have any problem with it..." The officer goes on to confirm "you could have (filmed) because you were within your rights and within our comfort zone."

In the following video segment, the investigators once again reinforce that filming police in public is completely legal.
Police Internal Affairs Interview Part 4/5

Q. In West Covina anybody could, they're free to film

Cop 1: Not just West Covina

Q. You're with West Covina.

Cop 1: Yes.

Q. So you can't answer for the other departments

Cop 1: I can answer for everybody, yes. I can answer for everybody in California and everybody in the United States. You are free to film anyplace you're allowed to be legally.

Q. Right. I know that, that's what I started with. but.. reinforcing that, if someone sees someone in West Covina being pulled over by an officer you're saying they would go up to that car and film without any repercussion?

Cop 2: Remember we talked about the part before; if you want to film from what we consider a safe place, what everybody considers a safe place that's fine. The issue you may have is with the person we stop. He or she may not want to be filmed and that's within their rights. We don't deal with that.

Q. That's also in a public place so whether they like it or not, is irrelevent.

Cop 2: I'm just telling ya. We're not in that business. You're in that business. And if someone gets mad at you or doesn't get mad at you because of you filming that's..

Cop 1: But you know if you're- just put yourself in the officer's place. You pull somebody over, it's a relatively, you know its night, it's a relatively dark street. You see a car pull up, you cant see inside of it because its dark, you're gonna wonder what that person's doing there.

Q. You have to use your discretion.

Cop 1: You have to use your discretion. I'm gonna shine my flashlight at ya, if I see you're filming, and I recognize it as a camera and not a weapon, you know it's gonna be- ya know, I'm gonna be nervous about it- but it's one thing if I see you over there and it looks like you've got a camera but it looks more like a weapon I'm gonna probably react a little differently. So you have to- it's not just what's legal. You got to remember what's in the officers' mind.

Q. Respect his position.

Cop 1: Yes. and their paranoia, which is justified at times.

Cop 2: It's very difficult for us when there's one vehicle we stop and there's a second vehicle.

Q. Right, you gotta watch your back.

Cop 1: I've had two friends shot to death. On this department. So it's- those things are real. You know. And you can overreact obviously, to that threat or that possibility. But you still have to take precautions. Even if you're not overreacting, you have to take precautions. You know. You want to go home at night. So it's a very very fine line officers walk between your rights and our responsibilities. And being safe. So it's a difficult job. But it's one that has to be constantly reinforced with our standards, the departments standards, besides the law. The law is fairly clear. But our standards and our, the things we want from our officers, the things we want our officers to do and say, have to be reinforced constantly. So that's what we use any complaint as. Even if it's something that the officer didn't do anything wrong, but he could have done something a little bit better. So we're looking for the A+. You know, C's not good enough. We'll tolerate B's. But we're always looking to give the officer additional ways of dealing with a situation that's gonna not only be legal, not only be right but be best possible way with the best possible outcome.

POSTSCRIPT: After my complaint, the Police Chief of West Covina sent me a letter thanking me for bringing my concerns to them. However, they never confirmed (or denied) wrongdoing of Detective Tedesco, and never answered any of the very specific legal questions outlined in my complaint. That shows what happens when the police investigate the police. As you will see in the police interview though, police internal affairs investigators clearly confirm upon my questioning that IT IS NOT ILLEGAL TO FILM POLICE IN PUBLIC. Got that? Even the police themselves in their official capacity admit that we can film police. This is not confusing.

Despite this fact, On 1/27/09, I had another encounter with police in West Covina, CA. You can see the video directly below. This video now has almost two million views. I will be the first to admit that I do not like this video. I did not handle the situation in the best way, (remember I was still new at this). I should not have given the first cop my ID, or gotten out of the car, or allowed the second cop to frisk me. I have learned a lot since then. I did NOT, however, turn off the videocamera as the disgusting cop kept demanding. My wife didn't turn off the camera either. So it was a win, and it exposes the criminality of these rogue cops.

What I DO like, however, is the amount of money I have made on this video and all my filming cops videos. I don't think youtube allows users to disclose the exact amount of money they earn on videos, but let me just say that it's freaking hilarious the amount of residual income I have made, doing nothing, on these videos for YEARS. I HIGHLY recommend it, LOL! ;-) When a cop says "turn that camera off" as in the videos below, I literally hear a "CHA-CHING!" in my head and keep rolling. Here is the West Covina video from 2008 and also some of my most recent videos. Notice the difference in my demeanor.


Checkpoint Cop Offended When I Yell At Him About 4th Amendment (Article & Video) 7/8/14

Motorist puts police in their place at suspicionless internal checkpoint December 2, 2012 [Must see video- Featured on PrisonPlanet.com].

Cop at Suspicionless Checkpoint Starts Barking Orders, But Then Flees from Camera [Featured on LewRockwell.com.]

Obnoxious CHP cop tries to make people stop filming him

Lunatic CHP cops go berzerk as female motorist successfully demands her rights under CA Vehicle code

DHS Calls Motorists' Employer to Tattle That They Won't Answer Questions At Warrantless Checkpoint

Here, a FAKE cop tries to tell me to leave the sidewalk! WOW.


How I beat a Speeding Ticket in California Superior Court of Appeals (Without A Lawyer) Court [Featured on LewRockwell.com.]

It's Your Right: How to Fight a Traffic Ticket in California Through The Mail ('Trial By Declaration') 2/15/14 [Featured on Economic Policy Journal.]

Requesting the "COUNTY SEAT" -An easy way to beat a traffic ticket using a pre-emptive measure

LibertyFight.com Traffic Ticket Archive

Red-Light Camera Archive

Martin Hill is a Catholic paleoconservative and civil rights advocate. His work has been featured in the Los Angeles Daily News, San Gabriel Valley Tribune, The Orange County Register, KNBC4 TV Los Angeles, The Press Enterprise, LewRockwell.com, WhatReallyHappened.com, Infowars.com, PrisonPlanet.com, Economic Policy Journal, FreedomsPhoenix, Haaretz, TMZ, Veterans Today, Jonathan Turley blog, The Dr. Katherine Albrecht Show, National Motorists Association, AmericanFreePress.net, RomanCatholicReport.com, WorldNetDaily, OverdriveOnline.com, Educate-Yourself.org, TexeMarrs.com, Dr. Kevin Barrett's Truth Jihad radio show, Strike-The-Root.com, Pasadena Weekly, ActivistPost.com, Los Angeles Catholic Lay Mission Newspaper, KFI AM 640, IamtheWitness.com, Redlands Daily Facts, BlackBoxVoting, The Michael Badnarik Show, The Wayne Madsen Report, Devvy.com, Rense.com, The Contra Costa Times, Pasadena Star News, Silicon Valley Mercury News, Long Beach Press Telegram, Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, L.A. Harbor Daily Breeze, CopBlock.org, DavidIcke.com, Whittier Daily News, KCLA FM Hollywood, The Fullerton Observer, Antiwar.com, From The Trenches World Report, and many others. Archives can be found at LibertyFight.com and DontWakeMeUp.Org.

  • Visit to the Mount Carmel Branch Davidian Massacre Site, 21 Years Later (VIDEO TAKEN July 14, 2014)

  • Texas Sheriffs Form Warrantless Checkpoints in Guadalupe River, Searching Witless Inner Tube Riders [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com, FreedomsPhoenix.com, Economic Policy Journal, strike-the-root.com, fromthetrenchesworldreport.com, RonPaulForums.com, thepriceofliberty.org.

  • Outrageous L.A. Court Tells Defendants: "Traffic Ticket Trials Not Allowed" [Featured on WhatReallyHappened.com and FreedomsPhoenix.com]

  • Man Who Refused Warrantless ID Check Arrested, Charged With 'Obstruction of Justice' in Georgia

  • It's Your Right: How to Fight a Traffic Ticket in California Through The Mail ('Trial By Declaration') 2/15/14 [Featured on Economic Policy Journal.]
  • Los Angeles Traffic Court giving nearly one year extensions due to furloughs 10/15/13
  • Why everyone should fight their traffic tickets - every time
  • Audio: Martin Hill of LibertyFight.com & Christie Czajkowski Discuss Fighting Traffic Tickets, Filming Cops, & The U.S. Police State.
  • How I beat a cell phone ticket in California [Article & video]
  • LibertyFight.com Traffic Ticket Archives


    Why I wasn't going to allow the squirly Walmart Guard to demand my receipt 3/20/13

    "Dancing Israelis" Arrested On 9/11 Later Sued The Govt, But Lost Their Case [Featured on Infowars, Rense.com, and Veterans Today.]

    Historical details reemerge: U.S. Government supplied 10 Million rounds of ammo, 10,000 Enfield Rifles, military planes & tanks to Slaughter tens of thousands of Catholic Freedom Fighters 10/17/13

    Bishop Fulton Sheen: Problems in Marriage: When marriage becomes 'dull' and when the spouse seems 'Impossible' 2/21/14

    1938: Fr. Coughlin explains the causes of Jewish persecution in Germany, warmongers falsely attack him as an Anti-Semite & Nazi 12/1/13

    Ron Paul on 9/11 conspiracies (in chronological order) Truly a classic.

    tumblr visitor stats